Shopify vs. Shopify Plus: When to Upgrade (and When Not To)

Shopify Plus sounds impressive with all the features like custom checkout, automation, dedicated support on offer. But do you actually need it, or is Shopify Basic more than enough?

In this article, we break down what the difference is between Shopify and Shopify Plus, when the upgrade pays off, and when it’s just overkill.

No hype, just clarity, formula, numbers, and usability insight.

Key Differences Between Shopify and Shopify Plus (That Actually Matter)

What’s the difference between Shopify and Shopify Plus?

At first glance, not much. Both give you access to the same dashboard, themes, app ecosystem, and overall structure. But once your business begins to scale, those small differences start to impact performance, flexibility, and conversion, especially when it comes to usability and checkout optimization.

Shopify is built for simplicity. It offers:

• A drag‑and‑drop editor and mobile-ready themes
• Easy onboarding for small teams (up to 15 staff accounts)
• 24/7 support and basic AI features (like Shopify Magic for product descriptions)
  

It’s a solid platform for lean, fast-moving brands. But for growing teams or businesses that depend on advanced flows, Shopify Plus opens a different layer of control.

Shopify Plus gives you everything in Shopify, plus powerful tools built for scale:

• Full checkout customization through Checkout Extensibility, allowing you to personalize the flow, add upsells, hide/show fields, and build logic for B2B or discount tiers;
• Advanced automation with Shopify Flow and Launchpad, perfect for campaign scheduling and high-volume sales;
• Multi-store support (up to 10 stores under one admin), which great for international brands;
• Unlimited staff accounts, higher API limits, and custom ERP/CRM integrations;
• A dedicated support team, including Merchant Success Managers and access to Shopify Plus Academy.

In other words, Shopify is usable out of the box, while Plus is customizable at scale. If your checkout is a bottleneck, or you’ve outgrown standard workflows, those Plus-only features can unlock serious ROI.

However, you can start with checking 10 Common UX/UI Issues in Shopify Stores before making any sudden changes in your Shopify tariff plans.

Shopify vs. Shopify Plus Pricing: Does It Make Sense to Pay More?

Shopify Plus starts at around $2,000/month, which sounds like a lot, especially compared to standard Shopify plans starting at $29. But the real question isn’t about how much it costs but how much it can return.

If upgrading to Plus improves your checkout conversion, even slightly, it could pay for itself (and then some). 

Here’s a clear way to calculate whether the upgrade makes financial sense. Just use these formulas:

Formula 1: Revenue Gain

Revenue Gain = (CR_new − CR_old) × Traffic × CVR × AOV

Formula 2: ROI

ROI = (Revenue Gain − Shopify Plus Cost) ÷ Shopify Plus Cost

Where:

• CR_old – current checkout conversion rate;
• CR_new – improved rate after customization;
• Traffic – monthly site visitors;
• CVR – % of users who reach checkout;
• AOV – average order value ($);
• Shopify Plus Cost – typically $2,000/month.

Seeing is believing. So, let’s start with an example and numbers.

Let’s say you get 100,000 visits/month, 10% reach checkout, and you increase your checkout conversion rate from 40% to 45%. With an AOV of $80:

(0.45 – 0.40) × 100,000 × 0.10 × $80 = $40,000/month

Subtract the $2,000 cost of Shopify Plus, and you're left with $38,000 in additional profit (yep, all from a 5% conversion increase). That’s the power of usability optimization at scale.

So, if your store has strong traffic, solid margins, and a bottleneck at checkout, Shopify Plus pricing isn’t a cost but a growth investment.

Here is the calculator to count the ROI to see whether it’s worth upgrading to Shopify Plus or not.

{{block}}

Shopify Basic vs. Shopify Plus: When It’s Worth the Upgrade and When It’s Not

Shopify Plus offers powerful features, but not every store needs them. The real question is: are you paying for performance, or just because others do that?

Here’s a quick checklist to determine which version actually fits your business right now.

Stick with Shopify Basic if:

• You’re under $1M/year in revenue;
• You run a single storefront with a lean team;
• You don’t need to customize the checkout flow;
• Your current stack works fine without deep integrations;
• Your biggest wins will come from UX and conversion improvements.
  

Upgrade to Shopify Plus if:

• You’re doing $2M+/year and scaling fast;
• You need to optimize checkout with upsells, logic, or branded experiences;
• You operate across multiple markets or languages;
• You depend on ERP, CRM, or API-heavy workflows;
• You want automation, custom scripts, and faster support.
  

If Plus helps you convert better and scale smoother, it’s worth every dollar. If not, hold off and invest in optimizing the UX/UI you already have.